Ladson-Billings Article

The summation of this article is that the achievement gap is a superficial topic; instead, the issue is about the economic debt that has impeded the education of minority groups. The author insist that historical issues, moral dilemmas, and economic unfairness have accumulated throughout the years and has caused students of minority groups to have a less than a par shot at an equal education. The author seems to assume that if in the past an equal education would have been implemented, there would not be such a gap between white and colored students today. I do agree that students of minority groups have less opportunities available for success in their education. I, however, do not wholly agree with this concept of past endeavors causing the issue. I believe that the students of today are too far removed from historical educational deficits for it to be a major cause. For example, my family came over from Europe in the late 1800s with absolutely nothing. Members of my family were subjugated to becoming indentured servants in order to enter the country. My family continued to be uneducated and poor until my parents generation. However even with a lack of societal prestige and education, determination and vigor have caused an exponential growth in successful educations and lives of my immigrant family. That is a reason why I feel that historical inequalities are not a logical cause of the gap that exists in today's world. I am aware, however, of the fact that other students from minority groups are not as lucky as I was to live in a safe community with good schools. I do feel as if the economic discrepancies have a huge effect on the quality of education for minority groups. Growing up near a poor, urban area, I have seen the gross inequality of funds plaguing city schools. Students are not provided with adequate books, supplies, or effective teachers. However, I do not agree with the author stating that these economic discrepancies are possibly due to the amount of minorities that attend the schools.  I think that these economic differences are due to the wages and taxes of the neighboring communities. It is very unfortunate that students of minority groups do not have the opportunity to attend schools in affluent areas that receive a lot of high taxes. It is also unfair that better teachers and resources are not provided to these students.  However, I don't think funds are allocated based on race alone. The author concludes with the fact that the two issues that need to be changed to allow for the closing of the achievement gap are school desegregation and fund allocation. These are two difficult concepts that will only see a change if the whole societal structure were to change. In the Memphis City Schools, a lot of theses issues have been challenged. The Memphis City School absorbed the surrounding, rich Shelby County Schools. There goal was to increase tax flow into the city schools and also to end the engraved line between minorities in city schools and white students in county schools. This was a huge flop. The affluent cities of the county were enraged, and have now voted to leave the system to create their own school system. This breaking off will begin next year. Seeing this all play out, it seems to me that these concepts the author offers as solutions can not and will not be able to effect the country's education until drastic societal changes are made. Is this what she is referring to as historical debt? Probably so; however, does this really effect possible success of students of minority groups? I feel as if it does not. I think the solution is to provide these students with teachers who are intelligent, hard working, and care about seeing their students succeed. I also think that the community and family lives of students need to show improvements for them to succeed. If no one at home or in the community is rooting for them to get a good education, what is their motivation.   As for the economic issue of resource allocation, I think this is a city government issue. When Memphis City Schools received a lump sum from the Bill Gates foundation, they decided to put air conditioning in the city's school buses. This same year the start of school was delayed for several weeks due to insufficient funds. It's time to look at the people who control the allocation of the money for schools with a high number of minority students. The author enforces the idea that the issue of the achievement gap is a long standing issue that has no easy solution. I agree, but I think it's time to look at what can be done now instead of focusing on possible causes that have already passed.